Environmental Group Gives Annual 'Dirty Dozen,' 'Clean 15' Lists for Pesticides
By Kathleen Doheny
WebMD Health News
Reviewed by Laura J. Martin, MD
June 19, 2012 -- Apples again have the dubious honor of nabbing the top spot on the ''Dirty Dozen'' list of produce with unacceptable pesticide residues, issued by the Environmental Working Group.
EWG has also issued its updated "Clean Fifteen" list of produce least likely to be tainted with pesticides.
For the first time, the group also tested prepared baby food consisting of green beans, pears, and sweet potatoes. Its evaluation shows that some green bean and pear samples had pesticide residues, while sweet potatoes had virtually no detectable residues.
"Our advice to consumers is to choose the organic version of the fruits and vegetables on the dirty dozen list," Johanna Congleton, PhD, MSPH, an EWG senior scientist, tells WebMD.
While EWG scientists prefer organic versions of some produce, they do concede that ''eating commercially grown produce is better than not eating fruits and vegetables at all."
Another expert not involved in the report has some criticisms. "Their rankings are just very arbitrary," says Carl K. Winter, PhD, director of the FoodSafe program and an extension food toxicologist at the University of California, Davis.
He reviewed the findings for WebMD. "I think consumers should eat lots of fruits and vegetables, whether organic or conventional," Winter says, and there is no reason to fear these foods.
Dirty Dozen, 2012 Version
Besides apples, 11 other fruits and vegetables -- in order of the amount of pesticide residues, from more to less -- earned a spot on the Dirty Dozen list:
- Sweet bell peppers
- Nectarines (imported)
- Blueberries (domestic)
This year, EWG scientists added a "Plus" category to highlight two crops -- green beans and leafy greens such as kale and collard greens. They did not meet the criteria typically used for the Dirty Dozen list but were commonly contaminated with highly toxic organophosphate insecticides.
These insecticides, Congleton tells WebMD, are toxic to the nervous system. They have largely been removed from agriculture over the past decade. But they are not banned, so they still sometimes show up on crops.
According to EWG, pesticide exposure is linked with a range of other health problems, including hormone disruption, cancer, brain toxicity, and skin, eye, and lung irritation.
Clean Fifteen, 2012 Version
Making the updated "Clean Fifteen" list because they were found to be lowest in pesticides are:
- Sweet corn
- Sweet peas
- Cantaloupe (domestic)
- Sweet potatoes
Produce & Pesticides: Baby Foods
In the baby food evaluation, green beans tested positive for five pesticides. The evaluation of pears found 92% positive for at least one pesticide residue.
Sweet potatoes came up cleanest.
Making the Lists: Methods
The EWG has issued the lists for the past eight years. EWG scientists used pesticide testing data generated by USDA and FDA scientists to create the lists. In most studies, produce was tested after it was washed or peeled.
"Contamination was measured in six different ways," says Alex Formuzis, an EWG spokesman.
- Percent of samples tested with detectable pesticides
- Percent of samples with two or more detectable pesticides
- Average number of pesticides found on a single sample
- Average amount (in parts per million) of all pesticides found
- Maximum number of pesticides found on a single sample
- Total number of pesticides found across all samples of the same produce type
"The foods on the dirty dozen list contained the highest amount of pesticides," Congleton says.
Regarding the Clean Fifteen list, she says, "Some of them do have detectable levels of pesticides. However, they are the lowest out of all the foods we evaluated. Some had undetectable levels of pesticides."
Produce and Pesticides: Another View
Winter of UC Davis explains why he says the lists are arbitrary. "What they are not doing is addressing the three important components that scientists have to use to establish whether there is any risk," he says.
The three components include the amount of pesticide, how much is consumed, and how toxic it is.
Winter concludes that "the average amount of exposure is negligible."
"Consumers should not fear conventionally produced fruits and vegetables," he says. "The levels of residues are at levels so low there should not be concern."
Winter says he gets no funding from chemical, agricultural, or food industries.
The full EWG lists can be found at www.ewg.org/foodnews.
Health Solutions From Our Sponsors
©2012 WebMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved.